Pages

"But, why?": A Look at the Question Mark

Along with the period, the question mark is one of those marks of punctuation that seems almost too simple. But is it really a no-brainer? Do I really want an answer to that question, or is it rhetorical? 

The question mark mysterious, or it thinks it is, and sometimes that's the sexiest feature someone can have. Don't ask me why—the answer is mysteriously unknown. 

Types of Sentences Punctuated by Question Marks

End direct question

Why am I here? 

(Not) indirect questions

I was wondering why you were here. 

Rhetorical question

How did we end up in this mess? 

Choose to end rhetorical questions with a question mark or a period depending on just how rhetorical they are. If you don't want any doubt as to whether or not someone should answer you, choose an end-stop. 

Declarative questions

You've been here for ten minutes? 

Tagged questions and hedges 

You're not coming with me, are you?
I'm going to leave, OK?

The first is a special type of declarative sentence; the second isn't really a question—it's a hedge used to pad somebody's feelings. Either way, though, you're going to use the question mark—even if that question is a bit more rhetorical than genuine.

Usage Guidelines 

Interpolated question 

Most common in speech, the interpolated question is a question wedged between a pair of em dashes. Use a question mark whether you put a space on both sides of the em dash or not (it's a choice! Check out my dash blog here).

I heard—could it be true?—that he took the keys and is gone. 

Prepositions

Don't end sentences in prepositions, OK? This is an old-school rule that I admittedly subscribe to. Well, maybe not all of the time. Which is better:

To whom did you give my keys? 
Who did you give my keys to? 

The first one is "correct," but it sounds too formal. The second sounds more normal or common, but "whom" is technically correct, and that pesky "to" bothers me. Try to use another construction to avoid this issue entirely: 

Where are my keys? OR Who has my keys?  


Quotation marks

Check back for a post on punctuation and quotation marks (I'll put a link here). 

There's no simple answer for dealing with questions marks inside or outside of the quotation marks—it depends on the context. When the question is within the quotation, put the question mark inside. 

"Where is the key?" she asked. (When writing dialogue, don't capitalize the speech tag.) 

If the question is outside of the quotation—the sentence is the question, not the quotation—put the question mark outside. 

Did you hear her say, "I have the key"?

Other Marks 

There are special-usage marks such as the irony mark, the interrobang, and the inverted question mark (as used in Spanish). I'll be producing a blog dedicated to these soon, including the new ElRey mark introduced by Ellen Susan (check out the article here and a great editorial by my friend and colleague, Heather Manes,  "Punctuation Shapes Our Reality," here). 

GRAMMAR REBELS

You can rebel against tradition in two ways: Use the question mark where it doesn't belong, or refrain from doing so. 

End regular statements with question marks to indicate, as we often do in speech, a decision to require an answer to something that was not, in essence, a question. 

End rhetorical questions or questions that are more accurately described as statements with a period or other end-stop punctuation. 

However you decide to rebel, be mysterious. 


  
 

Copyright © Your Resident Grammarian. Template created by Volverene from Templates Block
WP by Simply WP | Solitaire Online